Grace Randolph’s Snyderverse Poll Isn’t the Win People Think It Is

Every few months, the Snyderverse fandom latches onto something new they believe proves their long lost universe is on the brink of returning.

This week, the hype machine centered around a poll posted by Grace Randolph asking fans if they want the Snyderverse back.

The reaction was… well…. predictable.

Snyder fans claimed victory, Cosmic Book News treated it like a seismic event, and social media lit up with “See? The people want it!” posts.

But when you actually look at the poll, the context, and the numbers, the so-called “win” falls apart instantly.

Grace Randolph’s poll pulled in over 17,000 votes. “Yes” earned 44%, while “Let James Gunn Cook” landed closely behind at 43%.

That alone should raise eyebrows as one percentage point is not a landslide.

But the deeper issue is participation.

Grace Randolph has a long history of blocking anyone who disagrees with her, across all fandoms. Snyder fans, Gunn fans, Marvel fans, DC fans… let’s face it she’s blocked thousands over the years.

Many of the very people who would want to vote in a poll like this either never even saw it or never had the chance to vote.

But let’s pretend the blocking problem doesn’t exist.

The math still doesn’t support the victory lap some fans are taking.

The poll had one pro-Snyderverse option and three anti-Snyderverse options.

“Let James Gunn Cook,”
“Give Gunn Oversight,” and
“Third Reboot.”

Add those three together, and 56% of voters chose some version of no Snyderverse. While only 44% voted for its return. That’s a loss, not a win.

This isn’t complicated. It’s basic math. Yet people are acting like the numbers confirm a mass movement. They don’t. They confirm the opposite.

Here’s the painful truth to some… Grace Randolph’s poll doesn’t influence studios. It doesn’t move executives. It doesn’t magically resurrect a Movie I.P.s. Al it is, is engagement bait… nothing more.

A Snyderverse comeback would require financial incentives so strong that a studio decides it’s worth reviving.

A Twitter poll run by someone who blocked half the potential voters doesn’t factor into that equation at all.

Hollywood operates on money, contracts, and long term plans… not on hashtags, vibes, or poll results.

A Snyderverse return could theoretically happen one day, because anything is possible in Hollywood. But if it does, it will be because a studio believes it will make money, not because 44% of voters on X hit “Yes” on a grifters poll.

This poll isn’t proof of anything. It’s noise. And the more people pretend it’s meaningful, the louder that noise becomes.