Hope Takes Flight: Superman’s Latest Test Screening Reactions reveal some interesting aspects of the film
The latest round of test screenings for James Gunn’s Superman has stirred up a fresh batch of discussion online. It is being said that while reactions were more mixed this time, the reviews have been more positive than not, largely because of the film’s unconventional narrative structure. But if you’ve been following Gunn’s career, or even just paying attention to what Superman is shaping up to be, that “mixed” label might actually signal something truly exciting.
Apparently, audiences were caught off guard by the film's unconventional format. Instead of the normal superhero movie arc people have come to expect with one big story, Superman is said to play more like a series of small stories, with each presenting Clark Kent/Superman facing a different challenge—possibly like shorts in an anthology.
If you loved Superman: For All Seasons or All-Star Superman, specifically the WAY those stories were told and structured, then James Gunn’s #Superman was specifically made for you. pic.twitter.com/cfawPiuzu1
— RJ (@ResonantJustice) March 29, 2025
By presenting the film as a series of shorts, Gunn may be leaning into the timeless quality of Superman—the idea that he’s not just a hero for one city or one crisis, but a constant, ever-present symbol of hope facing new dilemmas every day. It’s a structure that mirrors how many people experience Superman: as a set of moments, ideals, and stories that linger in the heart rather than just another beat-em-up blockbuster.
Sure, the audience reaction might feel uneven now—but that’s often the case with bold storytelling choices. Think of films like The Dark Knight, Logan, or even Spider-Verse. Each took risks with form, tone, or structure—and each ultimately redefined what a superhero movie could be.
It’s a character driven movie that follows the life of Superman and the challenges he faces during the events of one specific week.
— RJ (@ResonantJustice) March 29, 2025
There’s a narrative throughline with Lex and his schemes.
I think it sounds awesome. But we have 0 context. It’s all conjecture and speculation. https://t.co/AQnwHQZVWx
What we're hearing about Superman suggests it’s taking some creative swings—and that’s not a bad thing. Early reactions are just one part of the process, and they don’t always capture how a film will resonate once it’s complete. The fact that this movie feels so different from Gunn’s past work could be a sign that he’s challenging himself to tell a story that’s more heartfelt, thoughtful, and in line with what Superman stands for: resilience, compassion, and quiet strength.
So if this is a Superman movie that throws people off at first glance? Good. It means it’s not just another cape flick. It might just be the Superman story we didn’t know we needed.
